Whether you’re relocating, traveling for work, or just need a temporary place to land, choosing between a short-term or long-term rental can be tricky.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and the right option for you depends on your schedule, lifestyle, and goals for your stay.
At Compass Furnished Apartments, we’ve helped thousands of travelers, from medical patients to corporate consultants, find their perfect fit across Massachusetts, Connecticut, and New York.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through the key differences, pros and cons, and questions to ask yourself so you can feel confident in your decision.
What’s the Difference?
Let’s start with the basics:
-
Short-term stay: Fewer than 30 days
-
Long-term stay: 30 days or more
Here’s a quick side-by-side breakdown of how they typically compare:
| Feature | Short-Term Rental | Long-Term Rental |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Less than 30 days | 30+ days |
| Rate Structure | Charged nightly | Charged monthly (lower rate) |
| Flexibility | High (ideal for quick travel) | Moderate (may have notice periods) |
| Best For | Business trips, quick relocations, in-between housing | Extended work assignments, relocations, medical stays |
| Amenities | Hotel-style or compact apartments | Larger apartments, full kitchens, laundry |
Consider Your Trip Length and Purpose
The first (and most important) question to ask: How long will you be staying—and why?
-
1–2 weeks: You may benefit from a flexible short-term lease with the option to extend.
-
1–3 months: A monthly furnished rental likely offers better value and more space.
-
3+ months: Long-term stays can unlock significant savings and more home-like comforts.
Your purpose matters too:
-
✔️ Working remotely? Long-term gives you more routine and comfort.
-
✔️ In town for a project or client visit? A short-term lease may give you more flexibility.
-
✔️ Relocating for work? A long-term furnished apartment makes the transition smoother.
-
✔️ Medical travel? Choose a place close to the hospital with a flexible end date.
Browse short-term and long-term rentals in your city.
Think About Comfort, Convenience, and Space
If you’re used to hotel rooms, switching to a furnished apartment—whether short or long term—can feel like a game-changer.
-
Short-term stays might feel more compact, but you’ll still get essentials like Wi-Fi, a kitchen, and a cozy living space.
-
Long-term stays often come with larger layouts, laundry machines, more storage, and space to settle in.
No matter which you choose, Compass apartments come fully furnished, cleaned before arrival, and move-in ready, so you can focus on your stay, not setting up utilities.
Budgeting and Cost Considerations
Here’s where the numbers come in.
-
Short-term rentals tend to cost more per night but don’t require a long commitment.
-
Long-term rentals offer lower nightly rates and potential discounts, especially for 60- or 90-day stays.
-
Look out for extras like cleaning fees, deposits, or utility charges in both cases.
Example Monthly Cost Comparison
| Feature | Short-Term Stay (2 weeks) | Long-Term Stay (1 month) |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | $150/night x 14 = $2,100 | $120/night x 30 = $3,600 |
| Cleaning Fee | $100 | $100 |
| Utilities & Wi-Fi | Included | Included |
| Total | $2,200 | $3,700 |
(Sample rates only; actual pricing varies by city and season.)
What Kind of Flexibility Do You Need?
This is where short-term stays really shine—but it depends on your situation.
-
Short-term = more flexibility, easier changes, fewer obligations.
-
Long-term = better rates, but you may have to give notice or sign a lease.
Compass offers flexible lease terms that adapt to your changing plans, especially helpful for medical travel, extended projects, or uncertain move dates.
Should I do a short-term or long-term rental?
If your travel dates are uncertain or your project is short, choose a short-term stay.
If you need consistency, more space, and better value, go for a long-term rental.
Use this checklist to guide you:
✅ Know your departure date
✅ Want lower costs per night
✅ Need extra space for work or family
✅ Don’t mind a longer commitment
If most of these are true, long-term is probably your best fit.
Which Stay Fits Best?
Still not sure? Let’s look at a few real-world examples.
A Traveling Nurse in Boston (Long-Term)
Maya relocated to Boston for a 13-week contract. She booked a long-term furnished apartment near the hospital, complete with laundry, kitchen, and parking—making it easy to focus on work and unwind after shifts.
👉 Read more about renting to medical professionals.
A Consultant in New Haven (Short-Term)
David traveled to New Haven for a 3-week corporate project. A short-term lease let him stay close to the client office without committing beyond the contract length.
👉 See how short-term housing supports business travel.
A Family in NYC for Medical Treatment (Long-Term)
The Lee family needed temporary housing during their daughter’s treatment. A long-term furnished stay gave them space, stability, and the comfort of home.
👉 Make short-term housing feel like home.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to how to choose between short and long term stays, it all comes down to your time, purpose, and lifestyle. If you’re unsure where your plans will take you, or how long you’ll be away, flexible housing options like ours at Compass can help bridge the gap.
Contact Compass for help finding the right fit for your travel needs—short-term, long-term, or somewhere in between.
Helpful Resources
About The Author
Lauren
Lauren, a passionate marketing professional from Vancouver, Canada, has an insatiable love for travel. Whether it’s camping off the grid in a secluded forest or enjoying the bustling streets of Manhattan, New York, she embraces every adventure with enthusiasm.